Skip to content
Back to Blog
Strategy7 min readNovember 20, 2026

Christmas guest follow-up: what to send after Christmas Eve, and when

A simple Christmas guest follow-up plan: one January next step, three short emails after Christmas Eve, and what your website should say on December 26.

Zach Green, founder of White Oak MediaBy Zach GreenPastor, production director & founder of White Oak Media

Christmas Eve is the night your church fills with people who don't usually come. A daughter home from college. A neighbor who finally said yes when you invited her in October. A family who found your service times on Google Maps that afternoon. They sing, they hold a candle, and they go home. Then most of them never hear from the church again. A simple Christmas guest follow-up plan, written before December gets busy, changes that.

I grew up in a church planter's home and I've pastored a small church, so I know what the week after Christmas feels like. The staff is worn out, half the volunteers are traveling, and the office is quiet until January. That's exactly why the follow-up has to be planned now, in November, while there's still some energy for it.

Why Christmas guests are different from Sunday guests

On a normal Sunday, a first-time guest usually came on purpose. They looked you up, they thought about it for a while, and they walked in. On Christmas Eve, a lot of people come simply because it's Christmas Eve. Some are visiting family and live three states away. Some come every December and nowhere else. Some haven't been inside a church in years and came because a friend asked.

That changes what good follow-up looks like. You aren't trying to sign anyone up for anything. You're trying to say thank you, and to give the people who live nearby one easy reason to come back on an ordinary Sunday.

It also means most of them won't leave their contact information, and that's fine. Plan for the people who do share it, and plan a way for everyone else to find their own next step.

Christmas guest follow-up starts with one January next step

Before you write a single email, decide what you're inviting people to. Not a list of options. One thing.

For most churches, the simplest answer is a new sermon series that starts the first Sunday of the new year, which this year is January 3. A series with a clear, human title gives a guest something concrete to say yes to. "We're starting a four week series on prayer on January 3, and it's a great place to jump in" lands much better than "Join us any Sunday."

A newcomers lunch in mid January or a short class for people exploring faith can work too. Whatever you choose, put a date on it and say it the same way everywhere: from the front on Christmas Eve, on your Christmas page, in your follow-up emails and on your home page. When a guest hears the same invitation three times in three places, it sticks.

How to collect contact information without making it awkward

Christmas Eve is not the night for a long connect card speech. People came for carols and candlelight. But you can make it easy for the ones who want to stay in touch.

Put a QR code on the screen during the welcome and in the program, pointing to a short form on your website. Ask for a name and an email, plus maybe one checkbox for "I live nearby" or "I'm visiting family." Give people a real reason to scan it: "If you'd like a note about our January series, scan this." Then move on with the service.

Some of your warmest contacts will reach you before they ever walk in, through a form on your Christmas page. I wrote about building that page in your church Christmas Eve page, and the end of that post is really where this one picks up.

What to send after Christmas Eve, and when

Here's the rhythm I'd set up at any church, big or small. It's three short emails, and you can write every one of them before Thanksgiving.

  1. December 26: a short thank you. No ask, no links beyond your Sunday times. Just gratitude that they spent Christmas Eve with you.
  2. Around December 30: the invitation. Name your January next step, the date and one sentence about what it is. Mention what to expect on a normal Sunday: the time, where to park, what happens with kids.
  3. The week of January 4: one last light note. If they came on January 3, welcome them back. If they didn't, mention the next week's message and leave the door open.

Then stop. If someone doesn't come back in January, they join your regular list like anyone else and hear from you when you have something worth saying. Three thoughtful notes feel like care. Seven feel like a campaign.

The thank you can be this simple:

"Hi Sarah, thank you for spending Christmas Eve with us. It was a joy to have you there. If you're ever around on a Sunday, we'd be glad to see you again. Merry Christmas, Pastor Mike"

Write it from a person, sign it with a first name, and let replies come back to someone who will actually answer them.

What about the guests who didn't leave an email?

Most of your Christmas guests won't fill anything out, so your website has to do the follow-up for them. Plenty of them will look you up again in the days after Christmas, curious and maybe a little moved. What will they find?

If your home page still says "Christmas Eve at 4 and 6" on December 28, it feels like the party is over. On the 26th, change the top of your home page to point at your January next step. Update your Christmas page to say something like "Thanks for joining us for Christmas. Here's what's next," with the series, your Sunday times and a link to your plan a visit page. And add a fresh post on your Google Business Profile about the series, so people who find you on Maps see the same invitation.

None of that takes long. It just has to be on someone's list before Christmas, because nobody remembers it on the 26th.

Who is going to send it?

The week after Christmas is the worst week of the year to depend on someone's memory. So pick one person now, staff or volunteer, and give them the three emails already written. Most email tools let you schedule a message ahead of time, which means the thank you can be ready to go before anyone leaves for the holidays.

Better still, let the website handle it. That's why I build guest follow-up into every site we make. In Church Studio, every site has a Take a Next Step button. A guest who taps it gets a welcome email right away, written in your words, and their note lands in one guest inbox instead of a basket in the church office. The rest of the year it does the same job every Sunday, which I walk through in how to follow up with first-time church guests.

The point is the person

All of this is just a way of saying to someone, "We noticed you came, and we're glad you did." Some of the people in your room on Christmas Eve are closer to coming back than they've been in years. A short thank you and one clear invitation might be the nudge they were hoping for.

If your church is small or you're doing all of this yourself, Church Studio gives you a website with the Take a Next Step button and guest follow-up built in for $39 a month, and you can try it free for 14 days with no card. Grace and peace to you and your church this Christmas.

Photo by Cara Denison on Pexels.

Custom church websites

Want a site like the ones in this article?

Custom church websites are $295 a month, month to month, with no setup fee. Book a 20 minute call with Zach, or call or text (860) 854-4983.

Zach Green, founder of White Oak Media

Zach Green

Pastor & founder, White Oak Media · November 20, 2026

More Articles

Found this helpful?

Put these ideas into action — pick your services and get started today.

Simple pricing. No contracts. Cancel anytime.